https://www.landmarkchambers.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/RPearce-v-West-Berkshire-BC.pdf
Pitch planning permission lawful despite claim councillors were materially misled, High Court rules
News update November 2022-February 2023
The fight goes on!
More action after the World & FA Cups excitement, but this time it’s legal. Please read about the High Court challenge to West Berkshire Council, its outcome and our comments in the news blog.
Newbury resident to appeal High Court decision that went in favour of West Berkshire Council’s approval of the Monks Lane Sports Hub
https://www.newburytoday.co.uk/news/football-pitch-row-rumbles-on-9298087/
Date: 7th February 2023
Community Groups says that Judicial Review proves that West Berks Council still has no plan for a replacement of the football ground they closed 5 years ago – and urges a review of “wasteful” Sports Hub plans
Newbury Community Football Group (NCFG), a Community Interest Company who have been campaigning for many years to save Newbury’s local Football Ground have urged West Berks Council to scale back their plans for a £10m “Sports Hub” at Newbury Rugby Club, now it has been confirmed through a Judicial Review that the plans are not a replacement for the Football Ground in Faraday Road that the Council closed in 2018.
In a statement NCFG said:
Whilst the outcome of the Judicial Review went against the Claimant, the positive news is that the case does provide absolute clarity that the Council’s Monks Lane proposals are definitely and irrefutably NOT a replacement for the Faraday Road Football Ground that they needlessly closed 5 years ago.
A key question for West Berks Council to answer now, is why are they spending £10m and committing to a 40-year lease on a facility that provides limited access to local community sports groups, when a replacement 3G pitch-only scheme could be provided on the site for around £1m without the need to rent any land or pay huge annual subsidies to the Rugby Club.
Other pressing questions are:
• Why are there still no plans for a replacement football ground for Faraday Road, which has been closed for nearly 5 years?
• Why is the Council still enforcing a ban on organised children’s football at the Faraday Road football pitch?
• Why can’t the Faraday Road football pitch be re-opened with temporary changing rooms and toilets?
Lee McDougall from NCFG said:
“Regrettably each of the 1,666 days from when the Council closed the football ground until the Judicial review was a day when the local community could not use their local football pitch, despite the Council’s own Playing Pitch Strategy advising that they are at least 8 full-size football size short in the area.
To spend £10m of tax-payers money and commit to a 40 year lease on the scheme at Monks Lane is wasteful and offers very poor value for local tax-payers and sports groups, we urge the Council to scale back their plans at Monks Lane and use the saved capital to invest in building at least 4 other 3G pitches in West Berks, including utilising the Planning Consent they unanimously gave Newbury Community Football Group for a 3G pitch at Faraday Road in November 2022”
Newbury Community Football Group www.ncfg.uk
Contact Paul Morgan or Lee McDougall: press@ncfg.uk / 07767 817208
See the PDF below:
NewburyToday
Judicial review into Monks Lane sports hub falls in councils favour
https://www.newburytoday.co.uk/news/council-wins-latest-monks-lane-sports-hub-battle-9297427/
BBC
Newbury football ground: New sports ground plan set to go ahead
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-berkshire-64535466
Kennet Radio
High court decision on Newbury sports hub
Sports Hub decision: Council opposition leader responds
Campaigners say High court decision ‘good news for Newbury’
and meanwhile in Bracknell…
BBC
Bracknell Town FC submits new housing plan for stadium
NewburyToday – Judge to rule on Newbury football ground pitch battle
BBC – Newbury football ground: High Court to decide planning row
Here is the YouTube link to the BBC South Today interview with NCFG regarding the state of play with football in Newbury, the High Court challenge and WBC’s reaction.
£9,500 sought to pay for High Court challenge for Faraday Road
Below is the GoFundMe web page containing background information and where you can also donate to the High Court Challenge to West Berks Council.
